Providential Tension
I know I’m late with this bit. I’ve said it before, but my energy level is not the highest…it’s peaks and valleys with me and I’ve been in the valley since returning to my mountain home from the big trip, and though I do love to talk to y’all (like my Virginia lingo?), the ones here at home get first dibs on whatever I’ve got to give. If it sometimes seems like the things I write here are the leftovers, well…
Gracie and I did bring back colds in addition to the many happy memories. Then that Ben character had to go and drain the well a bit more dry by making his mother worry about him (”You know the pictures in the news of the most dangerous parts of the fire…that’s where I’ve been.”) Plus a birthday, plus more excuses, excuses.
But I still have a couple things to tell about our trip.
Fort Pocahontas, where the last two days of the Jamestown birthday celebration was held, is part of the estate owned by Harrison Tyler, whom I think I mentioned is truly the grandson of the tenth president, John Tyler (1841-1845), and who owns the ancestral property. Mr. Tyler is in his 70s, he was born when his father was in his 70s (Lyon Gardiner Tyler, official historian of the Jamestown tercentennial in 1907), who was born to the tenth president when he was in his 70s (John Tyler also had the distinction of being the father of 15 children). Think about that, and try to grasp how quickly that time has gone by, think of how the heritage of that family illustrates the short space of our national heritage. That man’s grandfather was president before the American War Between the States, before the California Gold Rush began. We blink our eyes and the moments are gone. That is why it’s so important to talk about the milestones, to mark them and remember them with special times of celebration.

Becky Morecraft, the “poet laureate” for the event
My friend Becky Morecraft demonstrated that beautifully on the second day at Fort Pocahontas, under the huge tent where we gathered for special talks and other highlights during the two days there. She wrote a lengthy poem to commemorate the entire celebration and to lead up to the dedication of the Children’s Memorial, the only monument made for the birthday of Jamestown. Becky’s poem was inspired by her own joy in telling stories to her grandchildren, who beg their grandma to do so whenever they visit with her. I’m not surprised, as Becky has a compelling way of telling a story with her lovely, lilting southern voice. Her poem was itself a story, about a grandfather sharing his personal memories of the beginnings of Virginia with his grandson who sat on his knee. I wish I could play a recording of it for you or link to the actual poem somewhere. I like to think I’m pretty good at reading aloud after so many years of practice with my children, but Becky, who has a very powerful singing voice (which you can hear on her sister, Judy Rogers’s, CDs) was superb with the cadence and emotion of her poem, whose refrain echoed perfectly the purpose of the entire event: “Remember God’s providence my son—remember, and persevere.”

The Jamestown Children’s Memorial, overlooking the James River at Fort Pocahontas
Gracie commented after we returned home that we couldn’t walk more than a few steps without stopping to talk to someone. Even waiting in line at the porta-potties we had some great conversations
. Several ladies I visited with noted how special it was to be in that place with so many sweet Christian families…sometimes we feel alone and get discouraged by negative reactions, even in the church, to our countercultural decisions. Homeschooling, having more children than is considered “normal,” and some of the other personal convictions lived out by the Christian families we met are met with anger and suspicion by some. Sometimes it’s people who see such convictions as “weird,” and sometimes there are those who feel judged knowing that such convictions are held because the ones who seem different choose to differ for a reason.
And sometimes the ones with the convictions are not so gracious to those who differ with them.
As we walked around Fort Pocahontas, we met people who wore head coverings, but we don’t. Some folks we met wear dresses only, and though I almost never wear pants anymore, my girls do. We homeschool, but there were those who came to Jamestown who are involved with Christian schools. Though longer hair was the norm for most of the women I saw, there were a variety of hairstyles and lengths. I even noticed one young man in the book tent whose hair was down to his shoulders, and I would have even talked with him if the opportunity arose
. Of course, there were lots of Baptists there, but we are of a more Presbyterian persuasion. And no, not even half the folks there were dressed in historical garb, though such clothing did lend a festive atmosphere to the occasion which was, after all, to remember an important time in the beginning of our nation’s history.

The lovely Miss Altman and her sister had some good talks with me about books, even though we California girls had skirts which went only a little past the knee that day
Which brings me to tell you about one of the best talks of the two days at Fort Pocahontas, by Paul Jehle. Dr. Jehle is the director of the Plymouth Rock Foundation, thus he gave a talk comparing the Plymouth settlement and the Jamestown settlement. Perhaps you have heard Jamestown unfavorably compared to Plymouth. Yet Dr. Jehle said that both form a cornerstone together and are a “balanced expression of kingdom principles.”
The controversy, of course, is that Jamestown was allegedly founded exclusively for commercial purposes while Plymouth was an exclusively religious colony which did not care about material profit. Dr. Jehle spoke of how both had religious as well as business-related ends, but that each had differing perspectives. Jamestown had a more “national” mission, founded as it was by leaders in England’s government (such as Edwin Sandys) and men who were involved with the state church. Thirteen years later, the founding of Plymouth was more local and small in scope and vision, by a group of Separatists from the church. For quite some time, the southern vision encompassed this more national and larger view, while the northern colonies had a more federal (as in de-centralized) idea of governing their affairs. This ironically switched later, as we see in the northern and southern views during the Civil War. But there was some conflict between the two groups initially, though both models came to temper one another eventually.
Then Dr. Jehle used this historic example to give us a present-day application. He talked of the way the Virginians considered the Separatists as arrogant and not honoring the king with their refusal to submit to the Church of England. The Separatists of Massachusetts thought the Jamestown settlers were compromisers who did not honor God, and they went too far sometimes with the idea of separation to the point of breaking fellowship with other believers who didn’t agree with them on non-essentials. Yet both colonies were founded on a religious mission and came with the Geneva Bible. Later on, we see the national mission of Jamestown and the federal mission of Plymouth balanced in the Constitution, which was not either/or, but both/and.
Our convictions are important, but we must learn how to live them out while also being a leaven in society. Dr. Jehle reminded us that we are not to be a trophy on God’s mantelpiece…we need to model humility. He told a story of a starving time in Plymouth in 1622, that happened not long after the starving time in Jamestown. A ship with supplies came to save the Massacusetts settlers just in time…from Jamestown, the place with which they wanted no associations as they considered their Church of England associations to be reprehensible. Yet they had to humble themselves and accept help from those they wanted to avoid. Governor Bradford called it a double blessing as they received the food and they learned to receive from the hand of God in ways they didn’t expect. Sometimes God needs to bring us out of pride and ignorance into humility to say, “Thy kingdom come, Thy will be done, on earth as it is in heaven.”
I appreciated Dr. Jehle mentioning something with which I wholeheartedly agree, as do most of those whom I know: the goal of restoring the family is not to worship it. We need to let our influence grow and leaven society. There is a godly tension of being both insular and outward in our convictions, just as we see the tension between the federal and national nature of our founding and our government (the way it was intended to be).
When I talked with those ladies about the blessings of being with the other families that week, I also noted that while it was a blessing to be there together, it was also a blessing to go home and live as lights for the Lord in all the places He puts us. Though in our churches and families we are benefitted as we have unity and work together for common goals, we also benefit from the trials of standing alone about some things and the challenge of loving others and bearing one another’s burdens even though we don’t perfectly agree on every little thing. Sometimes the rough edges that get rubbed off are our own.

Bonnie is a lady who could teach me lots…I wish we didn’t have an entire country between us, but it was a privilege to meet her and her family, too










